- 30 returns
- 1,099 yards
- 36.6 average
- Four kickoff returns for touchdowns
Bio: McElroy was the speedster option in sharing the load with Rodney Thomas and Greg Hill during his first two seasons at A&M. He ran for 229 yards in the 1995 opener against LSU. However, following a loss to No. 5 Colorado, the Aggies’ season and McElroy’s Heisman chances sputtered. He missed two games, but still finished with more than 1,000 yards. He still holds the school record for average all-purpose yards per game with 135 yards. He was picked by the Arizona Cardinals in the second round of the 1996 NFL Draft.